-1 to the last bit. I don't think all battles should be decided randomly because let's face it, a human character with a gun is going to win against a cat, and someone completely healthy shouldn't lose against someone who can hardly move.

However, I would like to see a lot less planning going on behind the scenes. If two characters run into each other and fight, the victor should be determined by how the fight plays out, not decided ahead of time. I think it's really weird to plan it out when they entered knowing their character was probably going to die eventually.

This is more of a suggestion for the RPers themselves than for the BR though.